logo head
farmland
about us issues member orgs get involved leadership development media resources
  EnergyHard Rock MiningClean Air and WaterFamily Farms and RanchingFood SafetyFactory FarmsFair TradeCorporate Responsibility

Beef Checkoff

Beef Checkoff Chronology

Supreme Court Decision Dismays Ranchers

On May 23, 2005, the United States Supreme Court ruled against WORC and the Livestock Marketing Association (LMA).The Court's opinion states that the mandatory beef checkoff is government speech and therefore does not violate the constitutional right to free speech.

Read WORC's press release

Read Court's Opinion

Read Statement by WORC spokesperson, Mabel Dobbs

Download the Courts Opinions in .pdf format:


Summary of the case
Opinion of the Court, Justice Scalia

Dissenting opinion, Justice Souter
Dissenting opinion, Justice Kennedy

Concurring opinion, Justice Thomas
Concurring opinion, Justice Ginsburg
Concurring opinion, Justice Breyer

 
About Us | Member Organizations | Issues | Get Involved | Leadership Development | Resources | Media | Site Map | Home